TAC was able to help out. I needed to uncheck "Convert broadcast arp requests to unicast" and "drop broadcast and multicast"
Here is what they sent me:
Please turn off broadcast filter arp/all in the Virtual AP profile and let me know if that works.
To disable the option via CLI:
wlan virtual-ap "<name of the virtual ap profile>"
broadcast-filter all
broadcast-filter arp
To disable the option via WebUI:
Configuration > AP configuration> AP Group > Virtual AP