@N3tw0rk3r wrote: Hi Parnassus, It seems my question has been misunderstood.
Believe me, it was not.
@N3tw0rk3r wrote:Here a clarification:
1. Specifications for Aruba 1000Base-SX transceivers according to the transceiver guide only make reference to a working distance of 550m for an OM2 fiber. No info about a better fiber like OM3 or OM4.
That's OK. It means that Aruba - actually - is not releasing any information - for whatever reason - about potential performance of their SR transceiver tested on those quality level cables (OM3/OM4).
@N3tw0rk3r wrote:2. Some vendors (like the bridge guys) have 1000Base-SX transceivers that for a better fiber than OM2 (eg. OM3 and OM4) can reach longer distances than 550m (see the attached document). It is maybe a plus if you compare it to the 1000Base-SX specification. But the point is that their transceivers could reach distances up to 1000m.
That's nice but then, using non Aruba branded transceivers, you're going down the unsupported path...so, that's my opinion, saying that others do it betters doesn't provide you the official answer you need (maybe someone, in a similar situation like you, will be able to provide you his/her advices...but those are, let me use the term, just unofficial).
@N3tw0rk3r wrote: Because public information of Aruba is for OM2 (550m), my intention is to verify that with OM3 or OM4 fiber the Aruba transceiver could reach or could not reach distances above 550m. If so, what woud be the distance limit?.
That's because Aruba decided to test Short Range (SR) Transceiver using OM2 and results say that 550 meters is the (probably conservative) distance under which you can trust your Aruba optics if deployed in that way.
You wrote that you want to verify...oK, if your goal is really to verify...do yourself a fast test and then report back (but probably you can't...so you're asking opinions, that's correct)...if your personal test result will produce a "Go" situation (100% reliable data communication up to, let me say, 800/1000 meters with OM3/OM4) then it will be a good unofficial "Go" (will be that an Happy End? I doubt...) for you and for all of us, if, instead, your personal test result will produce a "No-Go" situation (no 100% reliable data communication over 550 meters even if OM3/OM4 quality is used) then you're pretty fast forced to go back at the starting point and revisit your design.
@N3tw0rk3r wrote: If the answer is: No, for OM3 and OM4 fiber, Aruba Transceivers still have a maximum working distance of 550m, I agree with you, I would be the only responsible of the deployment above this distance, and if it does not work properly, I should assume the consequences of the error.
You will be the only responsible in any case ("Go" versus "No Go") without an offical answer/confirmation provided by Aruba to you...for your particular scenario or generically valid for any scenario...this beacuse there is no official result about any test done against OM3 and OM4 made by Aruba itself. It's very simple.
Then the only thing you can do is ask the vendor - Aruba - to test/certify (and so grant what they are able or want to certify)...if they aren't able or they don't want...you're stuck again to use the unsupport way at your own risk (!).
The only one (theoretical) error is starting a line of reasoning by assuming that if vendor X says something about its devices' peformances/limits then the vendor you want (or are forced) to use should declare the same...or should address your issue in the way you want. I suspect this approach is far from ideal and can be really challenging.
Let's do a test: Open a support ticket and ask Aruba to provide you evidence of what you're looking for (a proof that it would work as you want). Let we see what they answer your.
I'm with you, not against you...it's just the way one think that, sometime, could be like going into a dead-end road thinking that there is an escape exit just before the wall.
Edit: note the statement: "Longer link lengths up to 1000 or 2000 m at either one of the two or both wavelength regions can be
supported if the customer and the manufacturer agree on improved attribute values, modal bandwidth
in particular." on ITU Standard G.651.1 : Characteristics of a 50/125 µm multimode graded index optical fibre cable for the optical access network document.