I wish I could give you all the credit. However, deleting the ssh-host did not change anything.
LUCKILY, it for some reason made my brain click and wonder if my Firewall was blocking it. I logged in to my firewall and saw no traffic between the controller and the server. Realized I didn't have a rule to allow traffic on port 22 between them.
ICMP was allowed, but SSH was not. Which explains why I could ping, but not much else. A quick policy change and I am in business.
So in the long run, thanks for jogging my brain in the right direction!
#7210