In case anyone else is still having this issue like we were and can't do a proper fix. I found a terrible work around that will probably be overwritten with Windows updates and is generally bad practice ... it's literally just a terrible work around ... but it works if you are desperate.
Find two older copies fo the rastls.dll and rastlsext.dll files located in C:\Windows\sytem32 folder. Windows 10 build 10.0.10240 has ones that will work but build 10.0.10586 don't work.
On your computer navigate to C:\windows\system32\
Take ownership and give yourself full rights to:
rastls.dll
rastlsext.dll
remove them (move to your desktop if you want to keep a copy "just in case")
Copy over the two older versions into your C:\windows\system32\ folder (the ones I used were from 7/10/2015)
rastls.dll
rastlsext.dll
Reboot and recreate your WiFi profile network (didn't try without deleting the existing profile so you may not need to do this)
You may need to go to a command prompt and run:
netsh wlan delete profile name="profile_name"