Cloud Managed Networks

Hi

A customer of ours are having problems with SONOS after switching to AOS10. 
They do have a smaller setup of Instant AP's running AOS8 systems, and on this setup the SONOS has no problems.

AOS10 systems consist of newer AP-6xx and Aruba CX (6100) switches, wireless system was running 10.4.x but has later been upgraded to 10.5.x.
SONOS system is connected to cable on 6100 switches on an access port with some vlan.

There is a SSID with the same vlan, broadcast filter is set to disabled. This is usually the one thing you need to adjust in a AOS8 IAP setup if you are unable to locate streaming devices of some sort.
Client connected to the SSID is using SONOS APP to try to find the SONOS system to control playback etc.
The phone/APP is not able to find the SONOS speakers.
He has added most services he was able to find in documentation and on Airheads, without this solving the problem.

I was wondering if anybody has had any success in adding SONOS to AOS10 systems and are able to control it by using a APP on the phone. 
All feedback is welcome

Roar 

Sonos and other products like Chromecasts, Philips HUE use multicastDNS (mDNS) for discovery. You say your Sonos is wired in the same VLAN as your SSID which should be fine in my eyes. Disable broadcast filtering and multicast optimalisation. Maybe connect your Sonos also wireless to the same SSID without Wired.

What is the user-role/acl that a wireless client get?

Maybe you can share your CLI configuration?

Hi

A customer of ours are having problems with SONOS after switching to AOS10. 
They do have a smaller setup of Instant AP's running AOS8 systems, and on this setup the SONOS has no problems.

AOS10 systems consist of newer AP-6xx and Aruba CX (6100) switches, wireless system was running 10.4.x but has later been upgraded to 10.5.x.
SONOS system is connected to cable on 6100 switches on an access port with some vlan.

There is a SSID with the same vlan, broadcast filter is set to disabled. This is usually the one thing you need to adjust in a AOS8 IAP setup if you are unable to locate streaming devices of some sort.
Client connected to the SSID is using SONOS APP to try to find the SONOS system to control playback etc.
The phone/APP is not able to find the SONOS speakers.
He has added most services he was able to find in documentation and on Airheads, without this solving the problem.

I was wondering if anybody has had any success in adding SONOS to AOS10 systems and are able to control it by using a APP on the phone. 
All feedback is welcome

Roar 

Hi

A customer of ours are having problems with SONOS after switching to AOS10. 
They do have a smaller setup of Instant AP's running AOS8 systems, and on this setup the SONOS has no problems.

AOS10 systems consist of newer AP-6xx and Aruba CX (6100) switches, wireless system was running 10.4.x but has later been upgraded to 10.5.x.
SONOS system is connected to cable on 6100 switches on an access port with some vlan.

There is a SSID with the same vlan, broadcast filter is set to disabled. This is usually the one thing you need to adjust in a AOS8 IAP setup if you are unable to locate streaming devices of some sort.
Client connected to the SSID is using SONOS APP to try to find the SONOS system to control playback etc.
The phone/APP is not able to find the SONOS speakers.
He has added most services he was able to find in documentation and on Airheads, without this solving the problem.

I was wondering if anybody has had any success in adding SONOS to AOS10 systems and are able to control it by using a APP on the phone. 
All feedback is welcome

Roar 

Hi, 

I do have several Sonos devices and controllers (both wired and wireless) and have used AOS 10.3, 10.4 and 10.5 without issues. I do have broadcast filter disabled and also AirGroup disabled. wired and wireless are in the same VLAN.

Hi

A customer of ours are having problems with SONOS after switching to AOS10. 
They do have a smaller setup of Instant AP's running AOS8 systems, and on this setup the SONOS has no problems.

AOS10 systems consist of newer AP-6xx and Aruba CX (6100) switches, wireless system was running 10.4.x but has later been upgraded to 10.5.x.
SONOS system is connected to cable on 6100 switches on an access port with some vlan.

There is a SSID with the same vlan, broadcast filter is set to disabled. This is usually the one thing you need to adjust in a AOS8 IAP setup if you are unable to locate streaming devices of some sort.
Client connected to the SSID is using SONOS APP to try to find the SONOS system to control playback etc.
The phone/APP is not able to find the SONOS speakers.
He has added most services he was able to find in documentation and on Airheads, without this solving the problem.

I was wondering if anybody has had any success in adding SONOS to AOS10 systems and are able to control it by using a APP on the phone. 
All feedback is welcome

Roar 

Hi, 

I do have several Sonos devices and controllers (both wired and wireless) and have used AOS 10.3, 10.4 and 10.5 without issues. I do have broadcast filter disabled and also AirGroup disabled. wired and wireless are in the same VLAN.

Hi

A customer of ours are having problems with SONOS after switching to AOS10. 
They do have a smaller setup of Instant AP's running AOS8 systems, and on this setup the SONOS has no problems.

AOS10 systems consist of newer AP-6xx and Aruba CX (6100) switches, wireless system was running 10.4.x but has later been upgraded to 10.5.x.
SONOS system is connected to cable on 6100 switches on an access port with some vlan.

There is a SSID with the same vlan, broadcast filter is set to disabled. This is usually the one thing you need to adjust in a AOS8 IAP setup if you are unable to locate streaming devices of some sort.
Client connected to the SSID is using SONOS APP to try to find the SONOS system to control playback etc.
The phone/APP is not able to find the SONOS speakers.
He has added most services he was able to find in documentation and on Airheads, without this solving the problem.

I was wondering if anybody has had any success in adding SONOS to AOS10 systems and are able to control it by using a APP on the phone. 
All feedback is welcome

Roar 

Hi, 

I do have several Sonos devices and controllers (both wired and wireless) and have used AOS 10.3, 10.4 and 10.5 without issues. I do have broadcast filter disabled and also AirGroup disabled. wired and wireless are in the same VLAN.

Hi

A customer of ours are having problems with SONOS after switching to AOS10. 
They do have a smaller setup of Instant AP's running AOS8 systems, and on this setup the SONOS has no problems.

AOS10 systems consist of newer AP-6xx and Aruba CX (6100) switches, wireless system was running 10.4.x but has later been upgraded to 10.5.x.
SONOS system is connected to cable on 6100 switches on an access port with some vlan.

There is a SSID with the same vlan, broadcast filter is set to disabled. This is usually the one thing you need to adjust in a AOS8 IAP setup if you are unable to locate streaming devices of some sort.
Client connected to the SSID is using SONOS APP to try to find the SONOS system to control playback etc.
The phone/APP is not able to find the SONOS speakers.
He has added most services he was able to find in documentation and on Airheads, without this solving the problem.

I was wondering if anybody has had any success in adding SONOS to AOS10 systems and are able to control it by using a APP on the phone. 
All feedback is welcome

Roar 

Hi mkk

I will ask them if thats ok. I guess you still talk about AOS10, because on AOS8 i know it works, and the customer also are able to make it work in AOS8.

Roar

Hi, 

I do have several Sonos devices and controllers (both wired and wireless) and have used AOS 10.3, 10.4 and 10.5 without issues. I do have broadcast filter disabled and also AirGroup disabled. wired and wireless are in the same VLAN.

Hi

A customer of ours are having problems with SONOS after switching to AOS10. 
They do have a smaller setup of Instant AP's running AOS8 systems, and on this setup the SONOS has no problems.

AOS10 systems consist of newer AP-6xx and Aruba CX (6100) switches, wireless system was running 10.4.x but has later been upgraded to 10.5.x.
SONOS system is connected to cable on 6100 switches on an access port with some vlan.

There is a SSID with the same vlan, broadcast filter is set to disabled. This is usually the one thing you need to adjust in a AOS8 IAP setup if you are unable to locate streaming devices of some sort.
Client connected to the SSID is using SONOS APP to try to find the SONOS system to control playback etc.
The phone/APP is not able to find the SONOS speakers.
He has added most services he was able to find in documentation and on Airheads, without this solving the problem.

I was wondering if anybody has had any success in adding SONOS to AOS10 systems and are able to control it by using a APP on the phone. 
All feedback is welcome

Roar 

Hi mkk

I will ask them if thats ok. I guess you still talk about AOS10, because on AOS8 i know it works, and the customer also are able to make it work in AOS8.

Roar

Hi, 

I do have several Sonos devices and controllers (both wired and wireless) and have used AOS 10.3, 10.4 and 10.5 without issues. I do have broadcast filter disabled and also AirGroup disabled. wired and wireless are in the same VLAN.

Hi

A customer of ours are having problems with SONOS after switching to AOS10. 
They do have a smaller setup of Instant AP's running AOS8 systems, and on this setup the SONOS has no problems.

AOS10 systems consist of newer AP-6xx and Aruba CX (6100) switches, wireless system was running 10.4.x but has later been upgraded to 10.5.x.
SONOS system is connected to cable on 6100 switches on an access port with some vlan.

There is a SSID with the same vlan, broadcast filter is set to disabled. This is usually the one thing you need to adjust in a AOS8 IAP setup if you are unable to locate streaming devices of some sort.
Client connected to the SSID is using SONOS APP to try to find the SONOS system to control playback etc.
The phone/APP is not able to find the SONOS speakers.
He has added most services he was able to find in documentation and on Airheads, without this solving the problem.

I was wondering if anybody has had any success in adding SONOS to AOS10 systems and are able to control it by using a APP on the phone. 
All feedback is welcome

Roar 

Hi mkk

I will ask them if thats ok. I guess you still talk about AOS10, because on AOS8 i know it works, and the customer also are able to make it work in AOS8.

Roar

Hi, 

I do have several Sonos devices and controllers (both wired and wireless) and have used AOS 10.3, 10.4 and 10.5 without issues. I do have broadcast filter disabled and also AirGroup disabled. wired and wireless are in the same VLAN.

Hi

A customer of ours are having problems with SONOS after switching to AOS10. 
They do have a smaller setup of Instant AP's running AOS8 systems, and on this setup the SONOS has no problems.

AOS10 systems consist of newer AP-6xx and Aruba CX (6100) switches, wireless system was running 10.4.x but has later been upgraded to 10.5.x.
SONOS system is connected to cable on 6100 switches on an access port with some vlan.

There is a SSID with the same vlan, broadcast filter is set to disabled. This is usually the one thing you need to adjust in a AOS8 IAP setup if you are unable to locate streaming devices of some sort.
Client connected to the SSID is using SONOS APP to try to find the SONOS system to control playback etc.
The phone/APP is not able to find the SONOS speakers.
He has added most services he was able to find in documentation and on Airheads, without this solving the problem.

I was wondering if anybody has had any success in adding SONOS to AOS10 systems and are able to control it by using a APP on the phone. 
All feedback is welcome

Roar 

Hello

I'm working on the same case now. With both Sonos and Client on different AP - it works fine, but not on the same AP.

A setting that I believe is the culprit is this "deny-inter-user-bridging" which I can see in the show run, but for AOS10 there is no way to turn this off in Central like it is in AOS8. Not sure if this is by design or a bug, but hard to proceed when this is globally enabled.

Hi mkk

I will ask them if thats ok. I guess you still talk about AOS10, because on AOS8 i know it works, and the customer also are able to make it work in AOS8.

Roar

Hi, 

I do have several Sonos devices and controllers (both wired and wireless) and have used AOS 10.3, 10.4 and 10.5 without issues. I do have broadcast filter disabled and also AirGroup disabled. wired and wireless are in the same VLAN.

Hi

A customer of ours are having problems with SONOS after switching to AOS10. 
They do have a smaller setup of Instant AP's running AOS8 systems, and on this setup the SONOS has no problems.

AOS10 systems consist of newer AP-6xx and Aruba CX (6100) switches, wireless system was running 10.4.x but has later been upgraded to 10.5.x.
SONOS system is connected to cable on 6100 switches on an access port with some vlan.

There is a SSID with the same vlan, broadcast filter is set to disabled. This is usually the one thing you need to adjust in a AOS8 IAP setup if you are unable to locate streaming devices of some sort.
Client connected to the SSID is using SONOS APP to try to find the SONOS system to control playback etc.
The phone/APP is not able to find the SONOS speakers.
He has added most services he was able to find in documentation and on Airheads, without this solving the problem.

I was wondering if anybody has had any success in adding SONOS to AOS10 systems and are able to control it by using a APP on the phone. 
All feedback is welcome

Roar 

Ok, problem solved.

Issue is that "deny-inter-user-bridging" was a feature in earlier AOS10. When the devs removed that feature, they "forgot" to clean up this from the config in AP Groups that was created when this was a feature.. Factory-reset of an AP didn't solve this, so the config was still hidden in the Group config.

So - on tip from our local SE Mr. Leirvik I created a new AP Group from scratch and moved the APs to this new Group. Voila - "deny-inter-user-bridging" was gone from the "show run"! Sonos and several other issues the customer had was instantly resolved. phew

Hello

I'm working on the same case now. With both Sonos and Client on different AP - it works fine, but not on the same AP.

A setting that I believe is the culprit is this "deny-inter-user-bridging" which I can see in the show run, but for AOS10 there is no way to turn this off in Central like it is in AOS8. Not sure if this is by design or a bug, but hard to proceed when this is globally enabled.

Hi mkk

I will ask them if thats ok. I guess you still talk about AOS10, because on AOS8 i know it works, and the customer also are able to make it work in AOS8.

Roar

Hi, 

I do have several Sonos devices and controllers (both wired and wireless) and have used AOS 10.3, 10.4 and 10.5 without issues. I do have broadcast filter disabled and also AirGroup disabled. wired and wireless are in the same VLAN.

Hi

A customer of ours are having problems with SONOS after switching to AOS10. 
They do have a smaller setup of Instant AP's running AOS8 systems, and on this setup the SONOS has no problems.

AOS10 systems consist of newer AP-6xx and Aruba CX (6100) switches, wireless system was running 10.4.x but has later been upgraded to 10.5.x.
SONOS system is connected to cable on 6100 switches on an access port with some vlan.

There is a SSID with the same vlan, broadcast filter is set to disabled. This is usually the one thing you need to adjust in a AOS8 IAP setup if you are unable to locate streaming devices of some sort.
Client connected to the SSID is using SONOS APP to try to find the SONOS system to control playback etc.
The phone/APP is not able to find the SONOS speakers.
He has added most services he was able to find in documentation and on Airheads, without this solving the problem.

I was wondering if anybody has had any success in adding SONOS to AOS10 systems and are able to control it by using a APP on the phone. 
All feedback is welcome

Roar 

Ok, problem solved.

Issue is that "deny-inter-user-bridging" was a feature in earlier AOS10. When the devs removed that feature, they "forgot" to clean up this from the config in AP Groups that was created when this was a feature.. Factory-reset of an AP didn't solve this, so the config was still hidden in the Group config.

So - on tip from our local SE Mr. Leirvik I created a new AP Group from scratch and moved the APs to this new Group. Voila - "deny-inter-user-bridging" was gone from the "show run"! Sonos and several other issues the customer had was instantly resolved. phew

Hello

I'm working on the same case now. With both Sonos and Client on different AP - it works fine, but not on the same AP.

A setting that I believe is the culprit is this "deny-inter-user-bridging" which I can see in the show run, but for AOS10 there is no way to turn this off in Central like it is in AOS8. Not sure if this is by design or a bug, but hard to proceed when this is globally enabled.

Hi mkk

I will ask them if thats ok. I guess you still talk about AOS10, because on AOS8 i know it works, and the customer also are able to make it work in AOS8.

Roar

Hi, 

I do have several Sonos devices and controllers (both wired and wireless) and have used AOS 10.3, 10.4 and 10.5 without issues. I do have broadcast filter disabled and also AirGroup disabled. wired and wireless are in the same VLAN.

Hi

A customer of ours are having problems with SONOS after switching to AOS10. 
They do have a smaller setup of Instant AP's running AOS8 systems, and on this setup the SONOS has no problems.

AOS10 systems consist of newer AP-6xx and Aruba CX (6100) switches, wireless system was running 10.4.x but has later been upgraded to 10.5.x.
SONOS system is connected to cable on 6100 switches on an access port with some vlan.

There is a SSID with the same vlan, broadcast filter is set to disabled. This is usually the one thing you need to adjust in a AOS8 IAP setup if you are unable to locate streaming devices of some sort.
Client connected to the SSID is using SONOS APP to try to find the SONOS system to control playback etc.
The phone/APP is not able to find the SONOS speakers.
He has added most services he was able to find in documentation and on Airheads, without this solving the problem.

I was wondering if anybody has had any success in adding SONOS to AOS10 systems and are able to control it by using a APP on the phone. 
All feedback is welcome

Roar 

This setting I was talking about is a Global setting affecting all SSIDs. We do have this setting on a per-SSID basis called "Deny Intra VLAN Traffic". 

"Disables intra VLAN traffic to enable the client isolation and disable all peer-to-peer communication" - read more about it here Configuring Client Isolation (arubanetworks.com)

In addition to this we have ACLs on Roles, which I'm thinking you already use. Common is to deny rfc-1918 traffic and client to act as dhcp-server.

Ok, problem solved.

Issue is that "deny-inter-user-bridging" was a feature in earlier AOS10. When the devs removed that feature, they "forgot" to clean up this from the config in AP Groups that was created when this was a feature.. Factory-reset of an AP didn't solve this, so the config was still hidden in the Group config.

So - on tip from our local SE Mr. Leirvik I created a new AP Group from scratch and moved the APs to this new Group. Voila - "deny-inter-user-bridging" was gone from the "show run"! Sonos and several other issues the customer had was instantly resolved. phew

Hello

I'm working on the same case now. With both Sonos and Client on different AP - it works fine, but not on the same AP.

A setting that I believe is the culprit is this "deny-inter-user-bridging" which I can see in the show run, but for AOS10 there is no way to turn this off in Central like it is in AOS8. Not sure if this is by design or a bug, but hard to proceed when this is globally enabled.

Hi mkk

I will ask them if thats ok. I guess you still talk about AOS10, because on AOS8 i know it works, and the customer also are able to make it work in AOS8.

Roar

Hi, 

I do have several Sonos devices and controllers (both wired and wireless) and have used AOS 10.3, 10.4 and 10.5 without issues. I do have broadcast filter disabled and also AirGroup disabled. wired and wireless are in the same VLAN.

Hi

A customer of ours are having problems with SONOS after switching to AOS10. 
They do have a smaller setup of Instant AP's running AOS8 systems, and on this setup the SONOS has no problems.

AOS10 systems consist of newer AP-6xx and Aruba CX (6100) switches, wireless system was running 10.4.x but has later been upgraded to 10.5.x.
SONOS system is connected to cable on 6100 switches on an access port with some vlan.

There is a SSID with the same vlan, broadcast filter is set to disabled. This is usually the one thing you need to adjust in a AOS8 IAP setup if you are unable to locate streaming devices of some sort.
Client connected to the SSID is using SONOS APP to try to find the SONOS system to control playback etc.
The phone/APP is not able to find the SONOS speakers.
He has added most services he was able to find in documentation and on Airheads, without this solving the problem.

I was wondering if anybody has had any success in adding SONOS to AOS10 systems and are able to control it by using a APP on the phone. 
All feedback is welcome

Roar